Quote:
Mandisa was at a disadvantage from the start, she doesn't fit the 'image' like the rest and she had no room for error

I disagree with this comment. Ruben won and he was heavier. Scott Stayed on a long time and he was both heavier and unattractive. I don't think it has anything to do with her weight.

Ace gets the teeny bopper vote and they'll watch and vote if he read the phone book. Katherine is deserving of top 6 so her still being there is reasonable too. Bucky is usually in the bottom group. Why not this time? I think more country music fans watched this time because of the category and maybe less viewers who like soul watched? Also, the song did suck, but when there are fewer and fewer people to vote for, a sucky night will kill you.

Do I think she was the worst in the group? No, I thought Elliot and Paris really sucked. It is wrong that she's out but it isn't a real competition when its a voting system and not a judged system by people who know what they are talking about. We had this same discussion with Dancing with the Stars. I think this show is worse off because the judges no longer have a say in who moves forward.
Beware...The Belly Dancin Fish Swingin Lesbian Canuck!